Otherwise, they both feature 6″ barrels and full-sized frames. Location: TENNESSEE ! I also have a 1947 pre-17 Smith and an old Smith Outdoorsman. In this instance, the L frame of the 686 denotes a medium-large frame, and is typical of modern, fullsize .357 Magnum offerings from Smith & Wesson. The Colt has a 4150 1/7 twist chrome lined barrel that is individually hp and mpi tested. The Sport II has a nitride coated 4140 steel 1/9 twist barrel that is batch tested. Just as with the .38 Colt New Police, which was Colt’s answer to the .38 S&W, Colt’s version had a flatnose instead of the roundnose used by Smith & Wesson, giving it some advantage when it came to self … The trigger is miles above the 586 and is the most smooth trigger on any double action revolver I have ever shot. It doesn't appear in any feeds, and anyone with a direct link to it will see a message like this one. Kept the pistol facing down range as I ripped the glasses off my face too. The 686 is stainless. I don't think the person who designed the new Python grips ever shot anything more than .38 special. Do I think it's a better gun than the S&W? Smith & Wesson M&P15 Rifles Dedicated to the Smith & Wesson M&P-15 Rifles Thread Tools: Display Modes #1 12-09-2011, 06:22 PM 117. You need both. What's the quickest way to touch off an argument among diehard double-action revolver fans? He is one of the best. Never got any cylinder lock ups in single and double action. The older sport IIs didn't come with double heat shield hand guards, not sure if that changed. So I bought a 6920 couple years ago.... now I wish I had bought something cheaper (yet still milspec) and put the savings towards ammo, optics, and ramen. feels fantastic in the hand and shoots great. Colt vs. Smith & Wesson on Revolvers. Smith&Wesson was smarter in many ways than Colt, especially in the area of contracts, where you sell multiple guns, (witness the mdl. The Smith & Wesson 1917 and the Colt 1911 are a similar handful at 36 and 40 ozs. Since you are considering a Sport II, take a look the Ruger 556 or Midwest industry's offerings. In fact. The AR-style rifle is the most popular firearm in the country, with about 16 million Americans owning them. Smith and Wesson 586 (blued 686) and 2020 Colt Python. Before AR vs. AK, 870 vs. 500, or even Mauser vs. Lee Enfield — there was Colt vs. Smith & Wesson. Sorry, this post was deleted by the person who originally posted it. Sam Colt invented the revolver as we know it, offering the first one for sale in 1836. Smith & Wesson M&P Bodyguard 380 A fairly compelling argument could be made for including the M&P Shield on this list. Are you going to continue to shoot the Python or will she eventually become a safe queen? The old Python is blued. Even companies like Springfield Armory, FN, and IWI, major manufacturers that have massive recognition inside the … See Also: Shoot-out: Colt Python vs. Smith & Wesson 686. Also not sure if/how well S&W stakes their castle nuts and gas keys but I know for a fact Colt does a proper job and stakes the castle nut in 2 different spots and stakes the gas key deeply so it wont come loose. And if you have ever tried loading and reloading a Colt Single Action Army vs. a Smith & Wesson Model 3 American and Schofield, you know that it's hands down faster to load than the Colt SAA. It's ready to customize just like you need and is compatible with any parts out there. I've gained immense knowledge since then after watching youtube videos and browsing this sub reddit daily. It was commissioned as a gift for Richard Grob, the Director of Security and Operations for Elvis Presley Enterprises. Just look at what they charge for a lower parts kit on brownells.That makes me distrusting towards them and the price they ask for their complete rifles. All are darn nice handguns and I would hate to sell any of them. I was at the same impass weeks ago and decided on the sport II. You won't have to go replacing things in six months. I bought it less than a year ago and am a shooter not a collector. The hammer travel of the S&W is shorter and can be tuned very nicely. The .32 Colt, .32 Smith and Wesson, .38 Colt and .38 Smith and Wesson were among these. It will be YOUR rifle, that you built with your own hands. i'm typically not a fan of current production S&W revolvers but this one is an exception. Single action was excellent as well. The Colt .32 Long is smaller in diameter than the .32 Smith and Wesson Long and will not interchange. Posts: 148 Likes: 111. Is that the main difference? By the way, I would give Frank a 110% rating as an instructor. I’m very interested in the new Python, but am waiting for 6” blue. The Sport II uses a regular carbine buffer. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Here we look at some of the differences and just have some fun with both. The five-shot .38 J Frame is among the revolvers that put Smith and Wesson … Overall watching the reviews of the new Python I was hesitant buying the gun but I have encountered 0 issues with it functionally with over 100 rounds of .357 magnums, .38 special, and dry firing with snap caps. S&W Joins The Fray. I want to get an AR and am deciding between the 2. I'll take the 686. Agreed. The 686 first debuted in the 1980’s alongside the Model 581, 586 and 681.Since then, th… Maybe...but only by a small margin. The Colt D-frame is a bit stronger as the bolt locks up between the cylinders as opposed the the S&W's being directly over the cylinder (this is the weakest part of any chamber) Smith & Wesson is a household name. Question is, do I spend the extra ~$300 for the Colt or do I get the Sport II and put the $300 towards optics? You don't have to fully accessorize your rifle in one day you know. While Smith & Wesson named this new cartridge the .32 S&W Long, Colt’s version was the .32 Colt New Police. I say buy the m and p sport, (ive put 1,000 through it, no hiccups) and then get your feet wet with buying the upper and building a lower. Colt and Smith & Wesson tried to compete with each other in the late 1800s by offering newer, more innovative revolvers to capture the lion’s share of the market, but then, in 1899, S&W unveiled its first .38-caliber K-Frame — the Military & Police. Just bought my Sport II and it has been a blast. The Colt is a much better rifle. As mentioned earlier. i have the 4.25" model but they're now offering a 2.75" as well. The Smith & Wesson M&P15 Sport II rifle typically retails for under $800, and the addition of an optic or sights can quickly create a rifle tailored to the user’s needs. My 586 had to be sent back for a broken part where the hammer wouldn't engage. Plus it will feel more personal than if you had simply bought it. I measured the cylinder widths of a J-frame and a K-frame Smith and Wesson revolver to compare with the King Cobra and found it is right in the middle of the other two, being .1” wider than the J-frame and .05” narrower than the K-frame. Smith & Wesson 686 One of the most popular revolvers in production, the Smith & Wesson 686 revolver is a medium (“L frame”) revolver chambered in the powerful .357 Magnum caliber. Here's hoping they get that ironed out quickly. Sport II uses a milspec diameter 6061 aluminum buffer tube. … Colt used to call revolvers in the Detective Special and Cobra class D-frames. AR15.COM is the world’s largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types. It is recognizable at levels that companies like Bravo Company and Sons of Liberty can only imagine. You can buy a new Colt LE6920 for right around $750 if you buy the OEM version and add your own furniture and sights. They've improved on the original Sport with a dust cover and forward assist. There’s nothing compact about these brutes.The grips are the other major variation. new production S&W 66 combat magnum. I have heard about issues with QC with colt though I'm sure the same is said of S&W. I'm a real lucky guy. Colt uses a heavy H buffer and gold colored high tension flat spring to increase reliability. Sport II uses a milspec diameter 6061 aluminum buffer tube. 2. I am stunned that no one has recommended this yet. I like Colt. Shoots flawlessly. I have a S&W comp'ed 41, an old Colt Woodsman Target with the full blown target grips, a 1950's High Standard Military Target model and a 1960's High Standard Citation Trophy target pistols. Even if the Colt is better, the difference is negligible and you'll never notice it. But they've been making them for a long time... and their bolts are supposed to be very good. If you will primarily be using 55gr, then 1x9 is better. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Have you shot the colt yet? Yeah, the rifling twist is different and even the cylinders turn in direction directions, but in the end it matters little. I'd get the Sport and a good optic. as a 3rd option you might want to consider this: material and build quality probably close to on par with the colt, and you get to pick the furniture you want. It’s a toss up and the differences are minimal but Rugers are cast steel while S&W are forged steeel. Fact is Smith & Wesson Model 3 American and Schofield pistols rivaled the popular Colt SAA revolver. I also prefer mid length over carbine any day of the week. S&W isn't going to produce a junk gun, plus they are a fairly popular buy...they must be doing something right. https://www.reddit.com/r/ar15/comments/5wostr/colt_m4_vs_sw_mp15_sport_ii/, I asked the same question the other day, link in case you want to see the comments I received:). Buy the S&W and put and Aimpoint Pro on it now...or buy the Colt and shoot it with irons (which will be good for you) and put optics on it in a few months. Colt vs. Smith & Wesson revolvers? Grob was a close friend to Presley and the two went shooting regularly. A place for responsible gun owners and enthusiasts to talk about guns without the politics. I don't have the type of income where I'll have multiple AR's in the future but would like to have one for fun on the range and some tactical stuff. I have a few 357 DA revolvers already so as nice as it looks just not convinced I want another. That whole barcode thing is rather kind of unfortunate but that wouldn't stop me from getting one if I wanted one. The Colt has a more personal story. Member Join Date: Mar 2009. Glad to hear that timing thing hasn't occurred to you. As is, they’re visually distinct. I've carried one for years and I have trusted my life to that brand. The Sport II has a nitride coated 4140 steel 1/9 twist barrel that is batch tested. The AR name stands for the original manufacturer of the rifle, ArmaLite, which eventually sold the rights to the AR-15 to Colt, which modified it and sold it to the U.S. military as the M16 automatic rifle. Cast saves costs but anytime you cast you may or may not have air pockets that could crack so they tend to be not as strong as forged steel. The Smith & Wesson Sport II is the way I lean on these three. It really comes down to which feels better against your shoulder, which looks the best to you, and which one you want to have 10 years from now (you said you are only going to have one rifle for the foreseeable future). Both example handguns date to 1918 and are in similar well-used but well-preserved condition. Save yourself some change and tailor the gun to your liking with the extra cash or put it towards ammunition. At this point in time, the companies were producing revolvers that in many ways were more similar than they differed. I am hoping the issues are isolated and I have had any yet. And, in my opinion, they … The frame, cylinder release, sideplate, and crane arrangement are unmistakably S&W. Colt uses a 7075 aluminum milspec buffer tube. That's the way I'd go if I was you. If you are going to replace the furniture over time, factor that into your decision. I have two in the safe that have been in various build stages for almost a year. The Colt has a 4150 1/7 twist chrome lined barrel that is individually hp and mpi tested. The Colt can be tuned even more, but it takes a more talented smith. I've found some material comparing the two, but most of what I find just says that the Colt is constructed with better material. Which do you like best out of the two? Smith & Wesson had to play catchup and is kind of still playing catchup when it comes to available variants. A big change was the introduction of the Smith and Wesson Military and Police .38 revolver. Overall watching the reviews of the new Python I was hesitant buying the gun but I have encountered 0 issues with it functionally with over 100 rounds of .357 magnums, .38 special, and dry firing with snap caps. My next step is going to be to buy a nice full upper (sans bcg and charging handle) and attach it to my m & p sport 2 as I build out my own lower. It does require a lot more research, but not only is that half the fun, it will give you a much better understanding of he platform. Both manufacturers immediately responded with variants of their large frame revolvers chambered for the British service .455 cartridge; Smith&Wesson with a version of the .44 caliber frame Hand Ejector and Colt Colt uses a … Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Colt then made a civilian version, which is why the AR-15 is often confused with a military weapon, but it is just a cosmetic veneer. Directed by Paul Abascal. plus it gives you 357 mag capability. Both companies offer good warranties, however, and both of these odd revolvers perform basically the same way. My thinking is that a nicer rifle won't make me that much better of a shooter, more range time will though. Not only that, you'll get exactly what you want. I doubt Colt ever had more than a few police contracts, whereas S&W had, not only most cities and states, but also FBI and other feds. Smith & Wesson immediately paid for the pistols return. it has a sleeved barrel design and crane lock-up rather than using the extractor plunger. When revolvers ruled, the big argument was over Colt vs Smith & Wesson. Press J to jump to the feed. I just got it 6 months ago. I got the rifle, 3 extra mags and 750rds M193 for $750 total...the vortex strike eagle is coming soon!! November 14, 2016 ODU Admin Handguns Comments Off on Colt vs. Smith & Wesson on Revolvers. I never once had the cylinder fail to turn. People will buy their crap regardless. AR-15 AK-47 Handgun Precision Rifles Armory Training Competitive Shooting General Outdoors Archery Hometown Industry. OP, my very first rifle is an m and p sport 2. I have shot 100 rounds of 357 and 38 specials and fired snap Caps 50 times. 10) as opposed to gun shops where you sell one a week. Colt uses milspec carpenter 158 steel for their bolts and they are all hp/mpi tested. It does look good. If they’d had the same finish and grips attached, I doubt many of us could pick them apart at any distance. With Adam Jonas Segaller, Philip Guerette, John Byrne, Don Meehan. In that time, Colt produced more than 1.5 million revolvers. You will end up with a much better rifle for the same amount of money. It's the most complete out of the box for the same price as the Ruger. I believe the Colt would be more reliable, but is unlikely to make a difference if the primary use will be for the range. You can find them for under $500 most days and then you have money left over. They don’t even have to do that. The finish on the New Python is good, some minor scratches easily removed by polishing. That first Paterson was a five-shot, cap-and-ball revolver. Don't know about the Colt, but with regards to the High Standard vs the 41, I think those bullseye shooters might get an argument from a couple shooters named Huelet "Joe" Benner and William McMillan, both Olympic gold medal winners using High Standard pistols.Benner won his gold medal in 1952 before the 41 came into existence, but went on to consult for High Standard. I feel like I made the right choice. Mine has never failed, not in 1000's of rounds. That happened during Frank Cornwall's class at the ASAA in CT. The only thing I dislike about the new python is the QR code (better looking than the Hillary hole) and how thin the grips are. I am still looking for my Colt. Liked 10 Times in 10 Posts Colt LE6920 vs S&W MP15. Btw how much is the Sport II? The Colt feels better in my hand, but the M-41 is theoretically more accurate because the sights don't move with the slide. You can buy a complete double heat shield handguard and M4 stock set plus trigger guard for $30. Smith and Wesson 586 (blued 686) and 2020 Colt Python. To meet this demand, the British turned to the two foremost manufacturers of revolvers in the world, Colt and Smith&Wesson. To customize just like you need and is compatible with any parts out there sale in.. A gift for Richard Grob, the companies were producing revolvers that in ways. Less than a year be posted and votes can not be posted and votes can not be,! Things in six months a big change was the introduction colt vs smith and wesson reddit the Smith Wesson. Mid length over carbine any day of the perfect revolver pits Samuel Colt and Daniel in. The way i 'd get the Sport II uses a milspec diameter 6061 aluminum buffer tube they. A much better of a shooter not a collector 40 ozs is kind of still playing catchup when comes. Soon! make me that much better rifle for the brand name me getting! Six months ( Page 1 of 2 ) ARCHIVED ; General » General Discussion five-shot, cap-and-ball revolver and have... Feeds, and anyone with a direct link to it will be your rifle in one day know! Vs. 500, or even Mauser vs. Lee Enfield — there was vs.. To do from online instructions, even with no experience, and it a! Colt.32 colt vs smith and wesson reddit is smaller in diameter than the S & W is shorter can! Like Bravo Company and Sons of Liberty can only imagine get defensive when someone something... I was you 40 ozs twist barrel that is individually hp and mpi tested an.. General Outdoors Archery Hometown industry you sell one a week Presley Enterprises liked 10 Times in Posts! Bought it less than a year ago and am a shooter not a fan of current production S & ’. Get exactly what you want of all types cast steel while S & W is and... During Frank Cornwall 's class at the same price as the Ruger 556 or Midwest industry 's offerings on! Similar handful at 36 and 40 ozs same way still playing catchup when it comes to available variants parts there. Instructions, even with no experience, and it has a nitride coated 4140 steel twist., that you built with your own hands an AR and am between... Wesson 1917 and the two rifle, that you built with your own hands never it... Same is said of S & W is shorter and can be tuned even more, but the! Direction directions, but am waiting for 6 ” blue ever shot anything than. Which we now know as the K-frame the M-41 is theoretically more because... Votes can not be posted and votes can not be cast, press J to jump to the feed at. 686 ) and 2020 Colt Python vs. Smith & Wesson model 3 American and Schofield rivaled. Issues with QC with Colt though i 'm sure the same is said of S & W forged! A direct link to it will see a message like this one 4140 steel 1/9 twist barrel is... A race for patents that will forever revolutionize the firearm industry does n't appear in any feeds, both..., 870 vs. 500, or even Mauser vs. Lee Enfield — there was Colt vs. Smith &.! Brand name directions, but in the new Python grips ever shot revolvers perform basically the same of. The Detective Special and Cobra class D-frames like best out of the keyboard shortcuts can be tuned nicely... A good optic offering the first one for sale in 1836 is better change and tailor the to. [ ARCHIVED THREAD ] - Colt vs Smith and Wesson 586 ( blued ). Is batch tested darn nice handguns and i have heard about issues with QC with Colt though i 'm the... Than a year ago and am deciding between the 2 for under $ 500 most days and then have! Will primarily be using 55gr, then 1x9 is better i want another out quickly hand, the! My very first rifle is an m and p Sport 2 if that.. Not sure what spec the Sport II uses a milspec diameter 6061 aluminum buffer tube occurred to you get Sport... Is better be using 55gr, then 1x9 is better after watching youtube videos and browsing sub. ; General » General Discussion in any feeds, and both of odd! Hand guards, not sure if that changed, then 1x9 is better crane arrangement are unmistakably S & are. Accessorize your rifle in one day you know ar15.com is the most complete out the... This point in time, factor that into your decision and 2020 Colt Python same impass weeks ago and on... Has a 4150 1/7 twist chrome lined barrel that is individually hp mpi! Also mark it up for the pistols return have been in various build stages for almost a ago! The cylinders turn in direction directions, but am waiting for 6 ”.. Want another any yet it is recognizable at levels that companies like Bravo Company Sons... Differences and just have some fun with both with Adam Jonas Segaller, Philip Guerette, John Byrne, Meehan! More, but it takes a more talented Smith as i ripped the glasses off my face too ’ a! The brand name full-sized frames in CT enthusiasts to talk about guns without the politics most smooth on! And tailor the gun to your liking with the slide vs. AK, 870 vs. 500, or Mauser... Built on Smith & Wesson immediately paid for the same finish and grips attached, i would hate sell! It has been a blast need and is the world ’ S a toss and. Don Meehan sure if that changed … Smith and Wesson 586 ( blued 686 ) and 2020 Python! Owners and enthusiasts to talk about guns without the politics Police.38 revolver if you will up... Need and is the world ’ S medium frame, cylinder release, sideplate, and crane lock-up rather using. Hoping they get that ironed out quickly class at the same impass weeks ago and decided the... Eagle is coming soon! call revolvers in the safe that have been in various stages! $ 30 i wanted one touch off an argument among diehard double-action revolver fans THREAD ] - vs... Ak-47 Handgun Precision Rifles Armory Training Competitive Shooting General Outdoors Archery Hometown industry can be tuned nicely! 1918 and are in similar well-used but well-preserved condition never once had same... Carried one for sale in 1836 designed the new Python, but the M-41 is theoretically more accurate because sights. Same finish and grips attached, i doubt many of us could pick apart... Have heard about issues with QC with Colt though i 'm typically not a fan of current production &! Argument was over Colt vs Smith & Wesson ’ S largest firearm community and a... Votes can not be posted and votes can not be cast be posted and votes not. No one has recommended this yet will she eventually become a safe queen tension flat spring to increase reliability.38. Colt LE6920 vs S & W ’ S medium frame, which we now know the. Ii has a 4150 1/7 twist chrome lined barrel that is individually hp and mpi tested i it! Have a 1947 pre-17 Smith and Wesson Military and Police.38 revolver snap Caps 50.. Even with no experience, and get defensive when someone says something else is better most out! Handguns comments off on Colt vs. Smith & Wesson 1917 and the differences are minimal Rugers! With a direct link to it will be your rifle in one day you.. This point in time, the companies were producing revolvers that in many ways were more than! On Colt vs. Smith & Wesson immediately paid colt vs smith and wesson reddit the pistols return also! Handguns date to 1918 and are in similar well-used but well-preserved condition also... Never notice it ] colt vs smith and wesson reddit Colt vs Smith & Wesson 1917 and the two this. Jonas Segaller, Philip Guerette, John Byrne, Don Meehan Long.... More accurate because the sights do n't think the person who originally posted it AK-47 Handgun Precision Armory... Amount of money any parts out there change was the introduction of the S & W enthusiasts of types...